Skip to main content
Ad (425x293)

Maresca faces midfield crisis as Fernandez struggles at City

Manchester City's midfield imbalance has become critical under Enzo Maresca, with Enzo Fernandez's positioning and defensive struggles leaving the team exposed in transition. Ayyoub Bouaddi offers a potential solution as a screening midfielder.

By The Sports Pulse Editorial Team·Source: Sky Sports··5 min read·How we work
Maresca faces midfield crisis as Fernandez struggles at City

Enzo Maresca has inherited a set of circumstances unlike anything Manchester City have experienced before. His early focus on football matters helped mask the broader turbulence engulfing the club, yet the peculiar nature of their predicament is now visible both in results and in how they perform.

According to Sky Sports, Maresca opened his tenure with seven consecutive victories across all competitions. That run has since given way to three Premier League defeats in succession. Performance issues in specific areas of the pitch were evident from the outset but have become increasingly glaring as the team's fortunes have deteriorated.

Where the biggest problems emerge

Tactically, Manchester City have become dangerously exposed. They are as vulnerable to being cut open through the middle as they are to balls played over the top. Newcastle have faced more shots generated from quick transitions than City's 17 this season—only the Magpies' 20 exceed that total—and City have already conceded two goals from such situations, including in their defeat to Nottingham Forest before the international break.

Vulnerability in transition moments has haunted City long before Maresca's arrival. However, the current tactical setup amplifies rather than alleviates the problem. Pairing Elliot Anderson with Enzo Fernandez in a double pivot creates a poor stylistic match when Rayan Cherki operates as the third central midfielder. The midfield becomes too easy to overrun.

Cherki contributes almost nothing when the ball is not in City's possession. This would be manageable if both deeper midfielders worked actively against the ball in unison. At City, that is not happening. Fernandez's positioning and his struggles in physical duels leave Anderson dangerously isolated. Even Anderson, one of the team's most dependable performers, was caught out at the City Ground, contributing to Liam Delap's opening goal.

The scale of the problem became apparent in the Forest match: City conceded eight fast breaks in total, a figure no team has surrendered in a single game this season.

Enzo Fernandez is drifting into spaces on the opposite side of the pitch when compared to where he played for Chelsea
Enzo Fernandez is drifting into spaces on the opposite side of the pitch when compared to where he played for Chelsea

Positionally, Anderson and Fernandez gravitate towards similar zones, both frequently active on the right flank of City's midfield. Measured per 90 minutes, the Argentine is making fewer tackles and winning possession less often than he did during his time at Chelsea, leaving the central third dangerously exposed. His attacking output does little to compensate for this defensive shortfall.

At the City Ground, Xaver Schlager and Ryan Yates exploited this imbalance ruthlessly. Schlager recorded a game-high 14 defensive contributions—clearances, blocks, interceptions and tackles combined—while Yates accumulated 11. Fernandez managed just four, fewer even than Cherki's five from the bench.

Elliot Anderson is also involved far more in the right side zones than the left
Elliot Anderson is also involved far more in the right side zones than the left

Maresca is taking a considerable gamble by fielding both players together. The situation is made worse by the fact that City spent over £320m overhauling their midfield this summer, yet the two £100m-plus signings have proven incompatible. That is a problem Maresca must resolve.

Ad (425x293)

The Italian is not attempting to replicate the model his Spanish predecessor built over 10 years, but in this instance, the question bears asking: What would Pep Guardiola do?

The Guardiola blueprint

Pep's teams consistently engineered numerical and positional superiority in midfield. Bernardo Silva mastered this art, and his departure may have damaged City's midfield balance more than Rodri's absence has. In theory, pairing Bernardo with Anderson would address many of the out-of-possession errors City are currently making. Yet the issue runs deeper than personnel.

If City are seeking another ball-winner to establish greater stability from midfield—someone capable of playing under pressure—Ayyoub Bouaddi emerges as the obvious candidate. The teenager has been underutilised in the league with just 177 minutes, but has had time to acclimatise to his new environment. Bouaddi's assured debut in Manchester City's 2-0 Champions League win over Porto suggests Enzo Maresca has assembled a midfield capable of functioning without Rodri.

Bouaddi brings physicality and exceptional athleticism, which would reduce the defensive burden on Anderson. He would also demonstrate greater positional discipline than Fernandez, adding another layer of defensive resistance.

For a team that has lacked control and been exposed through structural vulnerabilities by Sunderland, Ipswich and most recently Forest, additional midfield cover represents a straightforward tactical adjustment with immediate benefits. Bouaddi functions as a ready-made screening number six.

The alternative approach

Yet adding midfield depth does not necessarily require dropping the player Maresca fought hard to acquire just two-and-a-half months ago. If the goal is restoring balance, Fernandez operating at the apex of a midfield triangle could work as an alternative to Cherki, depending on the tactical approach. This remains a team that dominates possession and can score from multiple areas of the pitch.

Fernandez retains the ball effectively, draws fouls, times his box entries well and can both create and finish. He has not yet scored from open play for City, but according to a separate report, Fernández had one goal and no assists in eight Premier League appearances, plus one goal and one assist in four Champions League matches. He could offer considerable value in a free role with adequate defensive cover behind him. Cherki's creative qualities in that position merit consideration as well, but Maresca must prioritise defensive solidity through the spine given the current circumstances.

The immediate challenge

City face Fulham this weekend, having won their last 17 matches against them while scoring at least twice in each encounter. Exactly one year ago, Pep's City conceded four goals at Craven Cottage yet still emerged victorious in a 5-4 thriller. Maresca cannot afford to gamble in that fashion.

He must discover a way to strengthen the backline's protection during transition moments. Without doing so, City risk allowing this pattern of chaos to supplant control, potentially defining a season already burdened with considerable difficulties.

What comes next

Manchester City are scheduled to host Fulham in the Premier League on November 21, 2026. Following that fixture, City are scheduled to host Napoli in the Champions League on November 24, 2026, before visiting Arsenal in the Premier League on November 29, 2026.

Ad (425x293)

Related News