Skip to main content
Ad (425x293)

Itoje warns against win-at-all-costs culture in rugby

Maro Itoje distances England from win-at-all-costs mentality amid controversies in rugby and cricket, emphasizing integrity and respect for officials ahead of Saturday's clash with New Zealand.

By The Sports Pulse Editorial Team·Source: Sky Sports··5 min read·How we work
Maro Itoje has distanced England from a win-at-all-costs culture in the wake of the Sandpapergate saga

Maro Itoje has stepped back from any suggestion that England should embrace a win-at-all-costs mentality, drawing a clear line between competitive ambition and the kind of ethical compromises that have engulfed both rugby and cricket in recent weeks. According to Sky Sports, the England captain made his position clear ahead of Saturday's Nations Championship encounter with New Zealand at Allianz Stadium.

Victory over the All Blacks would represent a significant statement about England's trajectory a year before the World Cup final and could secure a place in the Nations Championship final on November 29. Yet Itoje insists that the pursuit of success must operate within firm boundaries, a stance that carries particular weight given the turbulence surrounding both rugby and cricket governance this week.

"There's a line," Itoje said. "I don't believe in the metric of win-at-all costs because, depending on what that cost is, it can be extremely damaging."

His comments arrive as South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus serves a six-match ban for his public criticism of match officials following the Springboks' defeat to France last week, during which he questioned whether the decisions amounted to "match fixing". The suspension marks Erasmus's third disciplinary action in five years for outbursts directed at referees, prompting rival coaches including Steve Borthwick, Eddie Jones and Fabian Galthie to call for greater respect towards officials.

The controversy in rugby has unfolded alongside the deepening Sandpapergate scandal in Australian cricket, where fresh allegations have emerged about the 2018 ball-tampering incident in South Africa. Test captain Pat Cummins now faces intense scrutiny following claims that knowledge of the sandpaper plot extended beyond the three players originally punished.

"Integrity is really important. I'm Christian as well, so there are certain things which I wouldn't do. There's a passage in the Bible that says something along the lines of 'what does it gain for a man to gain the world but lose his soul?' Part of that is why I don't believe in that kind of thing."

Cameron Bancroft has now backed Usman Khawaja's claim that the ball-tampering knowledge was more widespread than Cricket Australia's original 2018 inquiry concluded, and admitted withholding information during that investigation, according to AFP. Bancroft's account followed Khawaja's autobiography, *Sabr*, and a press conference in which Cummins called Khawaja's allegations "100 percent wrong." Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon have all denied knowing about the sandpaper plan before Bancroft was caught.

Australia's win-at-all-costs mentality has been cited by some as contributing to the 2018 incident, with Sky Sports Cricket's Michael Atherton arguing that it created a "toxic dressing room culture". The original inquiry concluded that Bancroft, then-captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner were responsible; all three were sent home and banned.

"Don't get me wrong, I want to win. I want to do everything within my power to win," Itoje added. "But if that power is taking performance-enhancing drugs or betting on the game, or I can list a number of other examples if that is the cost of winning, if I did those things and then win, what does the win really mean? I don't believe in that."

Ad (425x293)

Respect for referees must be maintained

Erasmus's repeated disciplinary issues have prompted calls from senior figures across the sport to demonstrate greater respect towards match officials. Itoje echoes that sentiment strongly, acknowledging the difficulty of the referee's role while defending rugby's reputation for maintaining standards of conduct.

"Often in this game referees get a lot of stick," Itoje said. "It's a tough old job. They get stick because people care about the game and want the right results."

He highlighted rugby's standing compared to other sports, noting that what distinguishes the game is the respect shown to officials.

"But when you're out and talk to people from different sports - particularly footballers - what people commend rugby for is how much respect we have for the referees. It's really important for us as a game and a sport to make sure we continue to respect the referees."

Itoje acknowledged that refereeing decisions will sometimes favour one team and sometimes another, and that not all calls will be perceived as fair.

"Some of the decisions they make will go in your favour, sometimes it'll go against you. Sometimes that's fair, sometimes that's unfair. Unfortunately, it's just the game. Otherwise perhaps we need to get AI to do the job, but I don't think anyone wants that either."

Cricket Australia says it will not reopen its investigation into the 2018 incident, but will establish a forum for players to share their experiences; chief executive Todd Greenberg said Cummins does not need to be "cleared," according to AFP. A poll of 13,000 readers by *The Australian* found 82 percent believed Bancroft and Khawaja over Cummins's denials.

Haka response will not determine the outcome

England have yet to decide how they will respond to New Zealand's haka, but Itoje made clear that whatever approach the team takes should remain secondary to the actual performance on the pitch.

"Our response to the haka isn't what is going to move the needle, it's what you do afterwards that matters," he added. "What wins you the game is being really physical, incredibly accurate and really clinical against a top side like New Zealand. That's what we endeavour to do."

What happens next

South Africa Rugby has requested a full misconduct hearing over Erasmus's suspension, seeking an opportunity for him to contextualise his comments, according to the Irish Examiner. Unless the suspension is overturned, Erasmus is set to miss South Africa's Ireland fixture and the Nations Championship finals weekend, as well as the Springboks' first four matches of 2027.

Australia's squad announcement for its home Test series against New Zealand has been pushed back; the series is scheduled for December–January.

Ad (425x293)

Related News